Easy Moist Banana Cake Recipe with Oil

You know that feeling when you walk into someone’s kitchen and there’s this warm, sweet smell in the air? That kind of hug-you-from-the-inside scent? Yeah, that’s banana cake—at least it is in my world.

Now, back when I was a kid running around my Nonna’s Philly kitchen, we didn’t throw away ripe bananas. Nope, those super spotty, nearly-black ones? Gold. She’d pop ’em in the freezer or mash ’em right up and turn ’em into something magic. Usually banana bread. But one day, when I was about 12, she let me take the lead. I remember standing on that squeaky old stepstool, grabbing the oil instead of the usual butter by accident. And guess what? That cake came out so tender, it was basically melting in our mouths. I mean, seriously, the texture was dreamy. She didn’t even yell—just gave me that look like, “Huh, not bad, kid.”

So this easy moist banana cake recipe with oil is sort of my redemption story—but in cake form. It skips the butter completely, uses oil for that ultra-moist crumb, and keeps things super simple with stuff you probably already have at home. That’s the beauty of it. No fancy mixers, no waiting on butter to soften, and definitely no tossing out those sad bananas.

Now let me tell ya, oil’s the secret sauce here. I’ve tried a dozen ways to make banana cake—with yogurt, with butter, with sour cream, even the ol’ brown sugar swap. But nothing keeps it this tender like plain ol’ vegetable oil. I’m talkin’ about a cake that stays moist for days (if it even lasts that long).

Want to make it even simpler? Use milk or yogurt depending on what you’ve got in the fridge. For a simple moist banana cake with oil and milk, just add a splash and cut back a bit on the eggs. If you’re going for that tangy kick, some folks love it as a banana cake with oil and yogurt instead. Both work beautifully.

Sometimes I pipe on the frosting all fancy-like, but more often than not, I just grab a spoon and slather it on. Cream cheese frosting’s the move, trust me. That rich, tangy vibe hits just right against the sweet banana base. But hey, if dairy’s not your thing, skip it or use your favorite dairy-free version.

Oh, and let’s talk texture. This baby bakes up light and fluffy, not dense like banana bread. You can throw it in a muffin tin and boom—cupcakes. Or split the batter between two round pans and layer it up like a showstopper.

If you’re looking for easy banana cake recipes with few ingredients, this one’s right up your alley. Just bananas, oil, sugar, flour, and a handful of pantry basics. Mix by hand, pour, bake, boom. Your kitchen’s gonna smell like heaven.

FAQs

What’s the secret to a moist banana cake?

It’s all about the oil, baby. Oil doesn’t solidify at room temp like butter does, so it keeps the crumb soft and tender for longer. Plus, don’t overmix and make sure those bananas are super ripe.

What is the secret to a very moist cake?

Aside from using oil, it helps to weigh your flour (or spoon and level it if you don’t have a scale), avoid overbaking, and don’t skimp on the wet ingredients. Moisture in = moisture out.

Which makes your cake more moist, oil or butter?

Oil wins this round. Butter has flavor, sure, but it can make cakes a bit heavier. Oil brings the fluff and the long-lasting moistness.

Does adding oil make a cake more moist?

Absolutely. Especially in banana cakes. The oil adds richness without weighing it down—plus it helps the texture stay consistent for days.

Print